Cave Story+ Review (2012): A Retro Gem Gets a Modern Upgrade
Cave Story+ is a reimagined version of Daisuke Amaya’s beloved indie classic, Cave Story. Originally released in 2004, the game was a standout in the world of homebrew titles, and its 2012 HD upgrade brought it into the modern era with new visuals, a revised soundtrack, and updated mechanics. The game follows the journey of a nameless hero who ventures into a subterranean world to rescue a group of bunny people from the clutches of a villainous doctor. Along the way, you’ll explore, fight bosses, and collect items that help you navigate increasingly complex environments.
A Thoughtful Upgrade with Some Controversy
While the upgrade has been widely praised for its improved presentation, it hasn’t been without its critics. On message boards, some fans have taken issue with the revised translation of Balrog, a boss who looks like a suitcase. His catchphrase, once "Huzzah!", is now "Oh yeah!" according to the HD version’s alternate translation. This change has sparked debate among long-time fans, with some expressing disappointment. One user, X-Calibar, even quipped, “‘Oh yeah’? What kind of charge is that?! Even ‘Booyah!’ might make more sense.” But if this level of scrutiny seems excessive, it’s a testament to how much love the original game has inspired.
Despite the changes, the core gameplay remains intact. Players continue to explore a vast, interconnected world filled with secrets, Easter eggs, and multiple endings. The game’s design ensures that each level feels intricate yet intuitive, maintaining a clear sense of direction even as the narrative branches in unexpected ways. The addition of new weapons and gadgets, such as double-jump boots and a machinegun that can be used for pogo-jumping, adds depth and variety to the experience.
A Game That Demands Multiple Playthroughs
Cave Story+ is not a game you can finish in one go. The sheer amount of content—hidden rooms, secret weapons, and alternate endings—means that even after completing the main story, there’s still plenty to uncover. The game’s levelling system focuses on weapons rather than the player’s character, rewarding skill and rewarding players who take calculated risks. This system encourages exploration and experimentation, making each playthrough feel fresh and challenging.
By the time you consider a second run, you’ll likely have joined the ranks of dedicated fans who spend hours mapping out the game’s levels, writing FAQs, or trying to beat the game in record time. The community surrounding Cave Story+ is passionate and active, which is no surprise given the game’s depth and replayability. Whether you're a newcomer or a longtime fan, Cave Story+ offers an experience that is both nostalgic and refined.
A Sensible Modernization
The developers at Nicalis have done an excellent job of updating the game without losing its charm. The soundtrack has been remixed to fit modern tastes while retaining the original’s whimsical tone. The visuals have been enhanced, but not at the expense of the game’s retro aesthetic. New art assets bring the world to life without veering into unnecessary modernization. This balance ensures that Cave Story+ feels both familiar and fresh.
In the end, Cave Story+ is a game that deserves to be revisited. Its combination of clever level design, engaging gameplay, and a narrative that rewards curiosity makes it a standout title in the platformer genre. While the changes may not satisfy every fan, the overall upgrade is a respectful and thoughtful tribute to a game that has captured the hearts of many. Huzzah—though some might prefer the original.
